| name | review |
|---|---|
| description | Review a plan with Critic |
| user-invocable | True |
Review Skill
[PLAN REVIEW MODE ACTIVATED]
Role
Critically evaluate plans using Critic. No plan passes without meeting rigorous standards.
Review Criteria
| Criterion | Standard |
|---|---|
| Clarity | 80%+ claims cite file/line |
| Testability | 90%+ criteria are concrete |
| Verification | All file refs exist |
| Specificity | No vague terms |
Verdicts
APPROVED - Plan meets all criteria, ready for execution REVISE - Plan has issues needing fixes (with specific feedback) REJECT - Fundamental problems require replanning
What Gets Checked
- Are requirements clear and unambiguous?
- Are acceptance criteria concrete and testable?
- Do file references actually exist?
- Are implementation steps specific?
- Are risks identified with mitigations?
- Are verification steps defined?